Canadian Startup and Video Game Law Blog

Why we don’t Incorporate Federally

Prospective clients often ask to incorporate “federally” or that they want a “Canadian incorporated” company. In most cases we recommend a provincial incorporation instead – here’s why:

1. Federal Falsehoods

At the start, it’s critical to dispel federal incorporation falsehoods:

First, federal incorporation does not allow the company to operate Canada-wide. Like a provincially incorporated company, a federal company must register in each province in which it does business (see separate nexus test), which involves paying an extraprovincial registration fee to each province (except Ontario, which is free for federal companies). Similarly, provincial companies must pay an extraprovincial registration fee in each province.

Second, federal incorporation does not protect a company name across Canada. The federal government uses the “NUANS” name reservation system, which has been adopted by some but not all provinces (British Columbia, for example, does not use NUANS) such that a federal company name is only protected in NUANS provinces. If you’re looking to protect a company name Canada-wide, the correct approach is to file a trademark.

2.  Residency.  Federal corporations are required to have a board of directors containing 25% Canadian residents or, if four or fewer directors, 1 resident director.  Conversely, certain other provinces do not have director residency requirements, for example British Columbia, Alberta, Ontario and Nova Scotia. As most startups receive foreign (often U.S.) investment, federal residency requirements quickly become a problem.

3.  Extra Provincial Registration. Since federal corporations are effectively foreign in all provinces (except Ontario), a federal corporation must immediately pay an additional extraprovincial registration fee based on the first province in which it does business. For example, a federal corporation based in British Columbia must pay roughly $450 in extraprovincial registration fees immediately upon incorporation, which for a cash-strapped startup is an unnecessary expense.

For all the above reasons, consider incorporating in your home province rather than federally (with some exceptions). Before taking the step to incorporate, be sure to speak with your legal advisors to determine which jurisdiction fits your particular needs.